Back to Guides

A short AI-narrated film with English captions. Pressing play loads the YouTube player. Watch on YouTube

Guide Origin: Official

A business case is the document that gives a decision maker the evidence and options appraisal needed to assess a spending proposal. UK government business cases follow HM Treasury's Five Case Model. This guide covers the five cases, the stages from strategic outline to full business case, who approves them, and how /arckit:sobc drafts a Strategic Outline Business Case (SOBC).


The Green Book and the Five Case Model

The Green Book (2026 edition) is HM Treasury's guidance on appraisal: comparing the costs, benefits and risks of options for meeting government objectives. It is mandatory for UK government departments and arm's length bodies when they develop proposals that involve significant public spending, and it should be used proportionately.

HM Treasury's Guidance on Developing Business Cases sets out the Five Case Model. It was updated on 30 June 2026 after the 2025 Green Book Review and now covers projects and programmes in one document. It says business cases are a mandatory requirement for significant spending decisions in the UK Government and the Welsh Government, and that everyone who develops, reviews or approves spending proposals there must be trained and accredited through the Better Business Cases programme.

The five cases are linked views of the same proposal, developed together rather than as five separate documents:

Case What it shows Contents (HM Treasury)
Strategic Strategic fit and a compelling case for change Strategic assessment, case for change, SMART objectives, existing arrangements, business needs, potential scope and service requirements, benefits, risks, constraints and dependencies
Economic Best value for money Critical success factors, longlist of options, preferred way forward, shortlist of options, analysis of social costs, benefits and risks, optimism bias, summary metrics of social value, sensitivity analysis, preferred option
Commercial Viable commercial arrangements with suppliers Procurement strategy, required inputs and outputs, risk allocation, payment mechanisms, contractual arrangements
Financial Affordability and agreed funding Budgeting treatment, accounting treatment, funding statement, contingency
Management The proposal is set up for successful delivery Governance, management, assurance and approvals; plan for delivery; change, benefits, risk and contract management; monitoring and evaluation

Heading into a gate, a procurement or a board? ArcKit FDE puts a senior architect in your team for five days to produce your principles, requirements, risk register and stakeholder map, at a fixed price. See how ArcKit FDE works.

Business case stages

HM Treasury's guidance builds a project business case up in stages, each reviewed by the approving authority before the next begins:

Stage HM Treasury name Purpose Assurance ArcKit document
0 Strategic assessment Initial planning: strategic fit and an initial view on feasibility Reviewed by the approving authority Not generated
1 Strategic Outline Case (SOC) Scoping: the case for change and the preferred way forward, from a longlist narrowed to a shortlist Gate 1: Business Justification SOBC (/arckit:sobc)
2 Outline Business Case (OBC) Planning: shortlist appraisal, the preferred option, and more detail on commercial, financial and management arrangements Gate 2: Delivery Strategy Not generated
3 Full Business Case (FBC) Procurement and final arrangements, ready for the investment decision Gate 3: Investment Decision Not generated

ArcKit calls its first-stage document a Strategic Outline Business Case (SOBC). HM Treasury's guidance calls this stage the Strategic Outline Case (SOC). The SOC focuses mainly on the strategic and economic cases, but must begin the commercial, financial and management cases too.

For a simple project whose strategic case has already been made in a programme business case, the guidance allows the SOC and OBC stages to be combined. It says this is not appropriate for more significant projects, or for projects with no overarching programme.


Options appraisal

The economic case starts with a longlist of options. HM Treasury recommends the options framework filter for generating and narrowing them. Longlist appraisal should then identify around five shortlisted options:

Option Meaning
Business as usual (BAU) What happens if current arrangements continue. It must always go to the shortlist as the benchmark. Don't assume the organisation would do nothing: BAU still has costs, benefits and risks
Do minimum The option that just meets the objectives. It must go to the shortlist
Preferred way forward The option that appears to best meet the objectives and critical success factors and offer the best value for money
More ambitious preferred way forward More social benefits, at higher social costs or with more risk
Less ambitious preferred way forward Lower social benefits, with lower social costs or less risk. It may be left out if the preferred way forward is also the do minimum

Options that do not meet the proposal's objectives must not go to the shortlist, apart from BAU.


Who approves a business case

HM Treasury's Treasury approvals process for programmes and projects (updated 1 April 2026) sets out when the Treasury must approve:

  • HM Treasury sets Delegated Authority Limits (DALs) for each department. A project or programme needs Treasury approval if its relevant costs meet or exceed any applicable DAL.
  • It also needs Treasury approval if it is novel, contentious, or could cause repercussions elsewhere in the public sector.
  • Departments should obtain Treasury approval of a project business case at each of the three key stages (SOC, OBC and FBC). They should usually get the SOC approved before making any public announcement.
  • A project whose costs start below the DAL but later rise above it also comes under the process.
  • Qualifying projects are considered at a single integrated approval point in HM Treasury.
  • The National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (NISTA) arranges independent assurance reviews for projects on the Government Major Projects Portfolio. The April 2026 update replaced the guidance's references to the IPA with NISTA.

Departments submit a business case to HM Treasury only after their own internal assurance. For digital and technology spend, the Digital Assurance Playbook replaced the digital and technology spend controls on 1 April 2026.


Using /arckit:sobc

Inputs

Artefact Purpose
Requirements (ARC-<id>-REQ-v1.0.md) What the project must deliver
Stakeholder drivers Business context and strategic alignment
Risk register Key risks and assumptions
Architecture principles Technology constraints and standards

Command

/arckit:sobc Create SOBC for <initiative>

Output: projects/<id>/ARC-<id>-SOBC-v1.0.md

Auto-versioning: Re-running this command when a document already exists automatically increments the version (minor for refreshed content, major for changed scope) instead of overwriting.

SOBC Structure (5-Case Model)

Case Contents
Strategic Case Why is change needed? Strategic fit, policy alignment, objectives
Economic Case What delivers best value? Options analysis, cost-benefit, VfM
Commercial Case How will it be procured? Procurement strategy, market engagement
Financial Case Is it affordable? Funding, budget, financial implications
Management Case How will it be delivered? Governance, timeline, assurance

Strategic Case Components

Component Contents
Strategic Context Policy drivers, strategic priorities
Case for Change Current situation, problems, why change is needed
Investment Objectives SMART objectives for the investment
Existing Arrangements Current state and its limitations
Business Needs What the organization requires
Scope What's included/excluded
Benefits Expected benefits and how measured
Risks Key strategic risks
Constraints Boundaries and limitations
Dependencies Related projects and external factors

Economic Case Options

The command follows HM Treasury's shortlist. By default it appraises five options: Option 0, business as usual (BAU), which is not "do nothing" and always has its own costs, benefits and risks; do minimum; the preferred way forward; and more and less ambitious versions of it. It appraises three when the preferred way forward is the do minimum, and more than five when alternatives differ in design. At SOC stage the result is the preferred way forward; the preferred option comes at OBC. See the options appraisal guidance above.

One-Page Workflow

Phase Key Activities ArcKit Commands
Discovery Define requirements and stakeholders /arckit:requirements, /arckit:stakeholders
Risk Identify and assess risks /arckit:risk
Business Case Create SOBC /arckit:sobc
Architecture High-level design /arckit:diagram, /arckit:hld-review
Procurement Market engagement /arckit:sow, /arckit:gcloud-search

Review Checklist

  • Strategic fit with government and departmental priorities clear.
  • Case for change compelling with evidence.
  • Investment objectives are SMART.
  • Around five shortlisted options, including business as usual and do minimum.
  • Preferred option has clear rationale.
  • Benefits identified with measurement approach.
  • Key risks and mitigations documented.
  • Procurement route identified.
  • Funding requirements clear.
  • Governance and delivery approach outlined.
  • Approval route confirmed: your department's delegated authority limits, and whether HM Treasury approval is needed.

Key Principles

  1. Evidence-Based: All claims supported by data and analysis.
  2. Options Appraisal: Genuinely consider alternatives.
  3. Benefits Focus: Clear, measurable benefits with owners.
  4. Risk Awareness: Honest about risks and uncertainties.
  5. Proportionate: Detail appropriate to investment size.